Understanding Your Obligations – It Is Not Just About Regulatory Breaches
Two recent actions by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), taken weeks apart, make the same point from very different angles. In the first case, a former law firm owner has been banned from financial services after misappropriating more than £28 million in client money, a case the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) published in its own press release at the time. In the second case, a former HSBC executive has been banned after a criminal conviction for dodging £5,900 in train fares. While the figures involved seem worlds apart, the regulatory outcome is the same: a prohibition from the financial industry, specifically “from performing any function in relation to any regulated activity carried on by an authorised person, exempt person or exempt professional firm, pursuant to s56 of the Act.”
Read the final notices here:
https://www.fca.org.uk/publication/final-notices/joseph-molloy-2026.pdf
https://www.fca.org.uk/publication/final-notices/nurul-miah-2026.pdf
What connects these two examples is the FCA’s assessment of ‘fitness and propriety’. In both cases, the ban was based on a finding that the individual lacked the honesty and integrity required to work in financial services. These outcomes were not down to regulatory breaches. They were a judgement about character, drawn from conduct that in one case, occurred entirely outside the FCA’s own regulated perimeter.
This is a stark warning for anyone holding a senior position in a regulated business, whether that is financial services, legal services, accountancy, or any other supervised sector; the implications are worth understanding.
The Fitness and Propriety Cases
In a final notice published on 15 September 2026, the FCA banned Nurul Miah from working in financial services. Miah was a non-legal manager at Kingly Solicitors Limited, where the SRA found he had dishonestly caused or allowed more than £28 million of client money to be taken from client accounts without permission between April 2019 and July 2020. More than £10 million was found to be missing and had been used for his own benefit. Miah had been separately approved by the FCA in 2016 to hold senior management roles at an unconnected firm, Oracle Consultants Ltd. The FCA concluded that his actions showed he lacked the honesty and integrity needed to work in financial services. Therese Chambers, the FC’s executive director of enforcement, said plainly: “He has no place in financial services.”
On 1 October 2026, the FCA published a final notice, detailing its reasons for banning Joseph Molloy, 53, formerly head of passive equity at HSBC Asset Management. The widely publicised case showed that Molloy had pleaded guilty to fraud by false representation after using a method known as “doughnutting” to avoid paying for the middle section of his daily commute from Orpington to Canary Wharf. He carried out the scheme at least 740 times between October 2023 and September 2024, saving himself £5,911. He also obtained a Jobcentre Plus discount, available only to unemployed people or those seeking work, to get 50% off ticket prices. The FCA said his conviction “demonstrates a clear and serious lack of honesty and integrity such that he is not fit and proper to perform regulated activities.” Molloy accepted the finding and did not challenge it. Source:
Independent – https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/hsbc-banker-banned-fca-train-fare-evasion-b3060226.html
Why This Matters Beyond Financial Services
The Miah case is significant because the misconduct occurred in a law firm, not in a financial services firm. The FCA did not regulate Kingly Solicitors; that position was held by the SRA. However, because Miah also held FCA-approved status at a separate entity, the FCA was able to act on what happened elsewhere. Subsequently, the misconduct in one regulated environment led to a ban in another.
That cross-sector reach is a key point regulated professionals should take away. Fitness and propriety requirements are not a ring-fenced assessment. A solicitor who also holds FCA approval, an accountant who is also a company director of a regulated firm, or a financial adviser who also sits on the board of a business supervised by HMRC can face consequences from multiple regulators for the same conduct, and for conduct that may not have occurred within the second supervisor’s own codes of conduct perimeter.
The Molloy case makes a different but equally important point. The conduct that prevents any future involvement in the financial services sector was not a regulatory breach at all. It was a criminal conviction for fare evasion. The FCA did not need to find that he had breached any rule in the Handbook. A finding that he lacked honesty and integrity was enough. The FCA’s prohibition effectively amounts to a lifetime ban from the industry over £5,900 in train fares, which puts the stakes of personal conduct into perspective for anyone holding a regulated position.
These are not isolated cases, and the FCA has been consistent in its stance: dishonesty outside the workplace is still dishonesty.
What Regulated Professionals Should Take from This
The FCA’s fitness and propriety assessment considers whether a person is honest, has integrity, and has a good reputation. It is not limited to conduct within regulated activities. A criminal conviction, a finding by another regulator, a disciplinary outcome from a professional body, or a pattern of personal conduct that calls honesty into question can all feed into that assessment.
For senior managers, COLPs, COFAs, MLROs, nominated officers, company directors, and anyone holding a position of regulatory responsibility, the practical implications are clear. Your conduct outside your regulated role can affect your ability to hold that role. A regulatory finding from one supervisor can trigger consequences with another. And the threshold for losing your position is not limited to breaches of the rules you operate under. It is a broader judgement about whether you are fit to be trusted.
How RACO Can Help
RACO works with regulated professionals across the legal, financial, and professional services sectors. Where a regulatory concern has arisen, whether from the SRA, FCA, HMRC, or a professional body, our Regulatory Defence and Disciplinary Support and regulated businesses investigations service helps individuals and firms manage the process and protect their position. For firms looking to strengthen their governance and reduce the risk of integrity-related findings, our Detailed Risk Management and Compliance Review, Training services for law firms and regulated businesses training services cover the obligations senior managers need to understand.
Speak to Our Compliance Team
To ask any questions about the Regulation and Compliance Office and how we can support your business, please call us on 0203 985 8550, complete the online enquiry form below, or email us info@regulationandcomplianceoffice.co.uk
